Neon Genesis Evangelion -dub- !!top!! File
The Evolution of the Eva Dub: From ADV to Netflix The English dubbing history of Neon Genesis Evangelion
- The New Cast: Casey Mongillo’s Shinji is more naturalistic and emotionally vulnerable, less "annoying teen" and more "traumatized child." Stephanie McKeon’s Asuka ditches the German accent for a sharper, more biting American teen voice. Ryan Bartley’s Rei is still soft but subtly more present. Ray Chase’s Gendo is cold and disturbingly calm. The overall production quality—sound mixing, consistency, lip-sync—is technically superior.
- The Changes That Made Fans Furious:
Reception & Cultural Impact
Changed terminology (e.g., "First Children" instead of "First Child") and notable changes in romantic/queer undertones. Neon Genesis Evangelion -Dub-
Shinji’s Vibe
| Feature | ADV Dub (1996) | Netflix/VSI Dub (2019) | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | | Whiny, fragile, angry | Soft, depressed, resigned | | Asuka’s Accent | Sarcastic, theatrical, vague | Realistic, less performative | | Translation Style | Liberal (Americanized) | Strict (Literal) | | Kaworu’s Confession | "I love you" (Romantic) | "I like you" (Censored initially) | | Ending Song | "Fly Me to the Moon" | Instrumental | | Audio Quality | VHS-era, inconsistent | Studio quality, crisp | | Fan Verdict | Beloved by purists | Professional but soulless | The Evolution of the Eva Dub: From ADV
- Sub-purists argue that Megumi Ogata (Shinji) and Yuko Miyamura (Asuka) are irreplaceable and that dubs lose the Japanese cadence of pain.
- ADV loyalists argue that the 2019 dub is an act of historical erasure, erasing the work that made Evangelion a hit in the West.
- Netflix defenders argue that the new dub is what Anno actually intended, free from the creative liberties of the 90s.
When Netflix acquired the streaming rights, they commissioned a brand-new redub to provide a more literal translation of the Japanese script. The New Cast: Casey Mongillo’s Shinji is more
- Netflix (Global Streaming): Only offers the 2019 VSI Redub. If you want to watch Evangelion legally right now, you are watching the Netflix dub. Note: The End of Evangelion movie is also on Netflix with this redub.
- GKIDS Blu-ray (The "Collector's Edition"): This is the golden ticket. GKIDS, which holds the physical home video rights, released a massive Blu-ray set that allows you to choose between both dubs. You can watch the ADV dub for episodes 1-26, the Manga Entertainment dub for Death & Rebirth, and the ADV dub for The End of Evangelion.
- Used DVDs (The "Platinum" Collection): If you find the long-out-of-print ADV "Platinum" DVDs, they contain the original dub but do not include the "Director's Cut" versions of episodes 21-24.
The English dub of Neon Genesis Evangelion is a subject of intense debate among anime fans, primarily because there are two distinct, competing versions: the original 1990s ADV Films dub and the 2019 VSI/Netflix redub.